Savidge Reads Man Booker Shortlist

Ok, now indulge me for a minute or three and let me imagine that I am one of the judges on the Man Booker Panel (which I won’t lie is one of my life’s missions) and I was in the position to choose what made it onto the shortlist, which of course is the big literary news of the day, just what would I choose? Well having actually read them all now (more reviews coming in between Sensational September when it starts tomorrow) I feel that I can finally give my verdict.

I won’t score them or anything like that, as its not something I do with my book thought posts, and I am not going to even try and guess what the judges are going to name as their shortlist. Instead I am simply going to leave you with the pictures of the covers of the six that are my personal favourites be it for the prose, the plot or just the way I reacted to the writing/characters/situations. Those six are…

  

  

Now I wonder how close I will come to the actual six, probably not very close at all but hey ho, time will tell. It was hard with Summertime and Love & Summer as I could have placed The Glass Room or How To Paint A Dead Man (reviews of both coming soon) in the top six, the later of the three particularily but I had to be tough and looking at prose and thought provoking reads the six above ticked all the boxes. There is nothing wrong with the seven I havent picked and I know some people may be shocked about’The Wilderness’ being missing, while I did like it, having now read it twice I still didnt really quite connect with it though and I have mulled that book over lots and lots now. I would be perfectly happy to see it in the short list though. Which ones wouldnt I want to see? I couldn’t possibly comment… on here, but maybe in an email ha!

Who do I think will win… it flips between four hourly and for all I know they may not even be short listed so I will comment on that nearer October and the winner being announced. Have you read any of the longlist? Who would you like to see short listed or even win?

12 Comments

Filed under Man Booker

12 responses to “Savidge Reads Man Booker Shortlist

  1. You and Jackie just amaze me. I think the both of you need to be on the panel! I’m lucky if I read one or two of the long list each year. Ha!

  2. Interesting choice! I think the only one from your short list which I would be shocked to see on the real one would be Me Cheeta. The list has been so strong this year that any of the books could make it. I would love to see Wilderness and The Glass Room on the list – we haven’t got long to wait now!

  3. Shortlist predictions at last possible moment:

    The shortlist I would love would have The Wilderness, Heliopolis, How to Paint a Dead Man, Summertime, The Quickening Maze and Brooklyn.

    The shortlist I instead expect to see has Summertime, How to Paint a Dead Man, The Children’s Book, Wolf Hall, The Glass Room, Brooklyn

    • 2/6 of my preferred list.

      4/6 of my predicted list.

      To predict 4/6 does not make me happy. I am disappointed about the absence of my favourites and dis-satisfied.

      I predict Coetzee for the hat-trick.

    • It’s an interesting mix the shortlist but have to admit am puzzled by it somewhat but as I keep reminding myself I am not a judge and maybe we need a prize the reading public can choose each year (and not one thats sponsored by some tv presenters and a chocolate company ha)

  4. Pingback: Off The Man Booker Mark… « Savidge Reads

  5. Amazing! I myself employ the big cheater approach – wait until the short list comes out and read those. I feel no guilt. I have you to do the rest for me. 🙂

  6. P.S. I Love You

    Wow. I never thought somebody would seriously consider ‘Me Cheeta’ to be on the shortlist in view of the other possible titles. Mind you, most of it went over my head and I never gave it serious consideration.

    • Why not? Have you read it, what didnt you like about it? I thought it fought its own corner (very like the narrator) very well and was different, mind you last year there was outrage about Child 44 another book I think is brilliant.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s