Heat and Dust – Ruth Prawer Jhabvala

I have never been fortunate enough to go to India in the real world, it’s one of my ‘when I win the lottery’ destinations, but I am always fascinated by the life and culture it has both now and in its past. This is where fiction is a joy because at the turn of the page, with the right author, we can find ourselves transported into the lives of people we could never meet and the worlds we can’t simply pop on a train to. Ruth Prawer Jhabvala’s deceptively small novel ‘Heat and Dust’, as the title states rather effortlessly, transports the reader into India not once but twice, in two very different time periods.

John Murray, paperback, 1975, fiction, 192 pages, from my TBR

There are two parallel stories running throughout ‘Heat and Dust’. In 1923 we have Olivia who, knewly married, moves to India when her husband Douglas gets a job there working for the British Government. Whilst there she meets the local ruling Nawab, a prince, which leads to (and this isn’t spoiling the story, we know this very quickly) an affair and her desertion. Fifty years later, after hearing of her grandfathers first wife who disappeared, we meet an unnamed woman who wants to find out more about this mysterious Olivia and just what happened to her after she seemingly vanished and starts to follow her trail.

What is so interesting about the book is how the events of both women start to mirror each other yet at the same time are completely polar experiences. They are both in the region of Khatm and yet, with the time between them, they seem like very separate worlds and ones that in each case Jhabvala sets the atmosphere incredibly. The world Olivia inhabits is one of lavishness, to the point of being spoiled, she has lots of money and often bored, verging on miserable, with either too much time on her hands of being forced into ‘socialising’ with other expat wives like the matronly Mrs Crawford and Mrs Minnies, women she doesn’t like and who don’t really like her. It is a world that bares almost no relation to the horrors her husband Douglas sees which the Nawab accepts which Jhabvala gives us occasional shocking glimpses of.

“It happened when Mr. Crawford was away on tour and Douglas on his own in charge of the district. A grain merchant had died and his widow had been forced by her relatives to burn herself with him on his funeral pyre.”

Her step-granddaughter (which seems an odd title as they never met) however inhabits the poorer, if slightly more developed, Satipur. There is the thrill of the new world and also the mystery of piecing this woman and her scandal together. It’s a world of community, the relationship between her, her landlord Inder Lal and his wife, who people believe is possessed by spirits when we could see she has epilepsy, Ritu, also adds a whole new dimension to the novel. This is the world of the ‘heat and dust’ that we are promised from the books title, it’s a foreign, exotic and occasionally scary world, yet she throws herself into the life that greets her, albeit after having to get somewhat accustomed to it.

“The family of the shop downstairs also sleep in this courtyard, and so does their little servant boy, and some others I haven’t been able to identify. So we’re quite a crowd. I no longer change into a nightie but sleep, like an Indian woman, in a sari.
It is amazing how still everything is. When Indians sleep, they really do sleep. Neither adults nor children have a regular bed-time – when they’re tired they just drop, fully clothed, onto their beds, or the ground if they have no beds, and don’t stir again till the next day begins.”

There is a lot of mystery and often some tragedy in ‘Heat and Dust’, yet there is also some bright humour there too, often Jhabvala mixes them at the same time, bittersweet moments or a laugh that casts a dark show. A section in the book where the unnamed narrator takes on an almost obligatory relationship with a fellow Englishman, Chid, who has converted and in doing so seems to have developed a rapacious sex drive had me laughing a lot. Jhabvala wants to add some lighter notes in a world where poverty and lepers are rife, after all for some this is the day to day and it has happy moments. In the case of Olivia’s story line we have her gossiping with the leech-like Harry, a man who has somehow got into the pocket of the Nawab which itself then adds a dark undertone to how manipilative this ruler can be and how controlling.

I thought ‘Heat and Dust’ was a marvellous book, I should add it won the Booker in 1975 – a controversial year. It is a book that is about a country at two very different points in time, the tale of failed marriage, the mysteries of people and love in the unlikeliest of places. Many writers would have needed to write a huge novel to tell this tale, instead what we have is a book you can get lost in for a single sitting and be rewarded beyond expectation. Its an epic distilled in a way, if thats not a cliche. That to me shows the power of Jhabvala’s wonderful prose. I thought it was marvellous. It shocked me it’s not been in print for some time, along with a lot of the authors other work (which I am keen to read), however it’s coming out through Abacus in October, I’d advise you get a copy.

Have you read this and if so what did you think? Have you read any of the authors other novels? I seem to be having a good run with more of the classic Booker novels like this and ‘Moon Tiger’ any others you would recommend?


Filed under Books of 2011, John Murray Publishers, Man Booker, Review, Ruth Prawer Jhabvala

17 responses to “Heat and Dust – Ruth Prawer Jhabvala

  1. I read this back in the 1980’s after seeing the movie, which I also loved. I thought both were marvelous. I think, at the time, they were both part of an India craze here in America brought about by The Jewel in the Crown mini-series which was broadcast on PBS about that time. David Lean’s A Passage to India came out around the same time as I recall.

    Everyone wanted to go to India, then. I still do. If I only played the lottery….

    • There was a real phase of everything India being wonderful in the mid-80’s wasnt there, I wonder why that was?

      I don’t know if I would want to see the movie having read the book as I enjoyed it so, though I have to admit it has faded a little bit over time.

  2. Eva

    I’ve read a couple of short stories by her and enjoyed them, so I’ve meaning to read one of her novels! Now I’ve put it further up on my list, esp since you mention it w Moon Tiger at the end. 😉

    I rather want to start a little mini-reading project by looking at women novelists who lived for long periods outside of their ‘born into/native’ culture and set their stories in that ‘other’ culture. That was an incredibly ungraceful sentence: I’ll have to work on another way to phrase it! 🙂 Anyway, authors like Pearl Buck, Anita Desai, etc.

    • This is a relatively short book Eva, not that that should make a difference (but it can do) and one that I think you would enjoy, it packs a punch thats for sure. I wasn’t expecting to enjoy it as much as I did. Moon Tiger has stuck with me much more than this one if I am 100% honest.

      I like the idea of your mini project, I am going to have to play blog catch up (apols) and see if you have started it.

  3. I came to this book, a long long while ago, via the movie and Ruth Prawer Jhabvala’s screenplays for Merchant Ivory. Unfortunately it didn’t really grab me. I wonder if it was lacking the visual appeal of a screen adaptation? I also wonder what I’d make of it now, many years later – which could turn into a project of re reading books from that far distant time. Would they still fall into the same like/dislike categories?

    • Hmmm maybe coming to it before the film was what did the trick for me Mary, and the fact that when I picked it up I had no expectations with it whatsoever. It has faded a little since reading but I still think its a captivating and interesting tale.

  4. This was an interesting period in India and the book should be good. Thank you for this review.

  5. I haven’t read this although I think I’ve seen the film many years ago. But my interest has been piqued so I may have to look for this one.

    • I liked going off and discovering a book that no one, that I know of, has been talking about lately. I think talking to the judges about all things Green Carnation, then the Man Booker hype etc meant I needed an escape and I got a very refreshing one.

  6. This is on my TBR list. If you want more India fiction you should definately pick up Rohinton Mistry’s ‘A Fine Balance’. I’ve almost finished it and it has been utterly brilliant. Made our recent stay there all the more magical.

    • I have been recommended A Fine Balance so many times Lucy it is untrue, and I will read it, the next time I have a long weekend. I promise, or maybe as a treat over Christmas, a classic and then that too.

  7. Pingback: 7 Book about India You Should Know and Read | vigilante publications

  8. Alice Smith

    If you like books about India, you must read A Suitable Boy, by Vikram Seth. It’s amazing.

  9. Reblogged this on post40postgrad and commented:
    Iam working on her for my PhD and would highly recommend ‘The Householder’ and ‘Esmond and India’ from early works and the short stories written in the USA. Follow me on Twitter rpj@BL . I haven’t blogged here for some time.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s