The Moving Finger – Agatha Christie

There are some authors that as a reader I will grab off the shelf if a) I am in some kind of reading funk or b) I have just read rather a heavy, yet rewarding, tome and need something in between starting another novel I suspect will be similar. Agatha Christie is one author that fits the bill for both, though that said I do have a random particular demand with a Christie, it can’t be a Poirot, I don’t like him for some reason, whereas I love a Miss Marple or standalone tale. So after something rewarding but weighty reading I decided it was time to pick up ‘The Moving Finger’ the third (or fourth if you include ‘The Thirteen Problems’ short story collection) Marple novel, a series I am trying to read sparingly.

Fontand Books, paperback, 1942, fiction, 197 pages, from my personal TBR

Jerry Burton is sent from London to the sleepy village of Lymstock on doctors orders and brings his sister Joanna in tow. Initially they are utterly charmed with the idyllic surroundings and quaint people that they meet. Yet soon they receive an anonymous poison penned letter accusing them of being lovers not siblings and they soon discover that most people in the village are getting equally scandalous letters too. Things soon take an even darker twist when one of the receivers of these letters dies, at first people think it may be suicide until the facts start to point to murder and another soon follows.

Hopefully that hasn’t given too much of the plot away, however I am about to let you into a small secret which led me to being rather frustrated with this book. Miss Marple herself doesn’t actually appear in the book until three quarters of the way through the novel, and then she is barely on ten pages or more as the novel closes. I am sorry to mention a negative so soon but it was Miss Marple I was really reading this book for, and rather like with ‘At Bertram’s Hotel’ (which I read out of order) I found myself most annoyed that my favourite character was barely in the book.

That said, to be fairer to the book and its author, ‘The Moving Finger’ isn’t half bad. Interestingly though I would describe it rather as I have the village of Lymstock, it is a mystery which is quite sleepy with dark edges. It was entertaining, had me guessing and kept me reading but it bumbled a little, lots of characters were introduced but interestingly more for Christie to write about quirky characters I felt than to create more suspects, which is normally the opposite of what I say with a Christie novel.

‘It’s rather like Happy Families, isn’t it? Mrs Legal the lawyer’s wife, Miss Dose the doctor’s daughter, etc.’ She added with enthusiasm: ‘I do think this is a nice place, Jerry! So sweet and funny and old-world. You just can’t think of anything nasty happening here, can you?

What I did really enjoy though in ‘The Moving Finger’ and stopped me from giving up (well apart from reading on for Miss Marple to barely appear) was Agatha Christie’s sense of humour. I don’t know if I simply haven’t noticed it before, or if it’s particularly prevalent in this book but there seemed to be a wry smile in almost every other page. It could be the descriptions of a character, one of the towns’ effeminate men gets this a lot, or it could just be a dig at the social ways of the time, either way it is definitely always there.

‘In novels, I have noticed, anonymous letters of a foul and disgusting character are never shown to women. It is implied that women must at all cost be shielded from the shock it might give their delicate nervous systems.
I am sorry to say it never occurred to me not to show the letter to Joanna. I handed it her at once.”

All in all I would have to say that ‘The Moving Finger’ isn’t my favourite Christie novel, but I still really rather enjoyed it. I had no idea ‘whodunit’, I enjoyed the setting of the English countryside where no one ever really knows what is going on behind closed doors and I really liked the underlying humour. Is it odd to say that with this book I felt I knew Agatha Christie a little better, because it is strangely how I felt?


Filed under Agatha Christie, Fontana Books, Harper Collins, Miss Marple, Review

10 responses to “The Moving Finger – Agatha Christie

  1. This is one Christie novel I have not yet read. Might put it in the middle of the pile of her TBR books although I like the comments about her humour. The Tod Claymore mystery (vintage Penguin) had quite a bit of humour and it really saved the book. Good review.. Pam

    • The humour was the thing that I liked the most about this book, that and the village filled with gossip. In terms of mystery though it isn’t her best but the other two factors make it worth a read.

  2. I just re-read this one a few months ago. I definitely wasn’t a favorite, but I didn’t mind it (unlike Nemesis, which is terrible). I also thought the romantic subplot was forced, too quick, and didn’t particularly work.

    • I didn’t mind it either Gail, I just didn’t love it and sometimes would put it down and leave it a while which is the first time I have ever had that happen with a Christie novel.

  3. I quite agree about Poirot vs Marple — don’t think I’ve read this one but you are right, these are perfect in between weighty tomes!

  4. I liked this one very much, I did guess the murderer very early on in the book, but still it was pleasurable reading.

    I have to say that I prefer Poirot to Miss Marple though. I feel in the Poirot books, Christie makes a greater effort to develop the suspense. Also, I loved the exotic locations – Egypt, Mesopotamia, the Orient Express, Petra…awesome.

  5. This is one of my favourite Chrisites. try Murder is Easy – another one set in a village with dark undertones. Crooked House is a stand alone which is one of her best I think

    Agatha can be very funny – I love her and have read her books numerous times – I find them comfort reads

  6. balade

    One of my favourite
    A classic example and a very well done execution on the troupe “hide a tree in a forest”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s