The Daylight Gate – Jeanette Winterson

There are some books with which, due to their subject matter, you find yourself being extremely excited about and all at once rather dubious or nervous about before you read them. This was the position I found myself in before reading Jeanette Winterson’s latest novella ‘The Daylight Gate’, for the revived Hammer Horror imprint, as the book centres around The Pendle Witches and their trial. These historical English events have just had their 400th anniversary and still to this day are rather seeped in myth and mystery. Would the book do justice to the legend or was this going to read like a commissioned cash cow? Those were my fears before I turned the first page.

****, Hammer Books, 2012, hardback, fiction, 194 pages, kindly sent by the publisher

‘The Daylight Gate’ opens with the events that really caused the Pendle Witch Trial. As pedlar John Law met Alizon Device on one of the many tracks around Pendle Hill, on the 21st of March 1612, and she asked him for some pins. He denied her where upon she placed a curse on him. It is from this point that several things including the effects of Alizon’s curse, rumours the Device family were all witches and a supposed meeting of witches in the Malkin Tower on Good Friday that lead to a trail of thirteen people, the biggest England had seen to date. One of these people was Alice Nutter, a loose thread in the whole trial as unlike the other twelve she was a woman on means and money. It is Alice that Winterson focuses on for her fictional telling of the events.

Through Alice we see the events as they unfold with the Device family as they live on her land; we also see what happens when she becomes accused and what life is like in the dungeons of Lancaster Castle, which Winterson brings almost too vividly to life. We also, through her past, get to see how society is at the time, from the reign of Elizabeth I, who we discover is in part responsible for Alice’s wealth, to the reign of James I, a man who brought fear to a nation through fears of his own. I did find the historical context really interesting and have since been off finding out more. I did also find it interesting that Winterson used Alice almost as a thread of narrative on how ill treated independent women were, and with what suspicion they were treated.

With a novel about witches and one by Hammer the natural question is of course’ is this book scary?’ Well no. However it has got the trademark Hammer Horror guts and gore theme running through it. In many ways, with rape, murder, witchcraft rituals and methods of torture all described in quite ‘The Daylight Gate’ is more horrifying than it is scary but that in itself is scary, just not in the ghostly way some people might be expecting. I certainly had no quibbles with being made to feel very squeamish rather than simply screaming my way through reading it.

My only slight quibble with the book was that Alice’s back story, whilst being an integral part of what Winterson’s fictional version of events and enjoyable, seemed to take over the book a little too much. For example she ends up meeting Shakespeare as the trouble is brewing in 1612 and then we hear how they met before, yet oddly it didn’t add anything to the story apart from placing Shakespeare in the narrative. I would have rather had those pages go back to Old Demdike and all that was happening in the castle as it was there that the book worked its magic the most.

Pendle Hill as taken by me in February, more on that tomorrow…

Overall though I was really rather spellbound by ‘The Daylight Gate’. I came away feeling like I knew more about the Pendle Witch trials, if not the witches so much, and how people’s lack of knowledge and some men’s desire for infamy created it all. I also just fell into the story even when it took me places I wasn’t expecting, but that in itself was all part of the enjoyment. I would definitely recommend this for curling up with on a dark and stormy night by the fire.

I will be back tomorrow with more from Pendle Hill itself.


Filed under Hammer Horror, Jeanette Winterson, Review

19 responses to “The Daylight Gate – Jeanette Winterson

  1. Louise

    I didn’t think much to this book actually, it was a bit of a slog at times. I’m a little obsessed with the Pendle lot, (and witches in general, Salem and whatnot) especially since it was on Most Haunted. I thought Daughters of the Witching Hill and Mist over Pendle was much better 🙂

    • Oh dear Louise, I am sorry to hear that. I thought it was rather good, I liked the atmosphere of it.

      I too got obsessed with Pendle and the witches thanks to Most Haunted which I really miss.

      I have Mist Over Pendle so I will have to give that a read next. I must look up the other title.

  2. I didn’t like it at all I’m afraid. I was hoping that Winterson might at least capture some of Lancashire’s atmosphere. But it bore no relation to the true story, and seemed to trade on all of the hoary old cliches about witches.

    • Did you not think it had links with the real story, or supposed allegations? I find that surprising, yes Winterson does give it a huge twist which heavily diverges but the atmopshere was wonderful I thought.

  3. gaskella

    I got this the other day, and am looking forward to it – unencumbered by any baggage of knowing much about the Pendle witches or the area either.

  4. I haven’t read this, but I do have a fascination for all things Pendle, having spent the past 2 years living there until very recently. Did you spot this news story last Winter? I haven’t heard anything more about it but would love to know what else they excavated:

  5. I can’t wait to read it, I;m waiting to get it from the book depository 🙂

  6. Pingback: Pendle Hill and the Pendle Witches | Savidge Reads

  7. My copy has just arrived!

  8. I’ve just picked it up this evening, and I like the spare prose style already. But it seems like the book has really polarised readers, and offended quite a lot of people because of JW’s rather loose approach to the historical facts. I’m usually pretty forgiving of historical inaccuracies in novels, but even I’m nervous about the whole Shakespeare bit!

    • It does indeed seem to have polarised the readers doesn’t it. The Shakespeare bit I didn’t really see the point in to be honest, that was probably the only bit of the book I didn’t feel needed to be in there.

  9. Pingback: Nytt på engelska. « Göta Petter!

  10. Ray

    I am huge fan of Winterson, so I am biased. I have not read this yet but I am greatly intrigued partly by the story itself and partly as a departure for Winterson. In the meantime, I found a wonderful documentary by the poet Simon Armitage on Youtube (called “The Pendle Witch Child”) well worth viewing

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s