When Nights Were Cold – Susanna Jones

Thank you all very much for your snowy book recommendations on Friday, as the snow had stuck on the Wirral (which apparently rarely happens) over the weekend I decided I would curl up with a book that was suitably icy, though as it turned out not one of the books you recommended – no offence. I had been meaning to read ‘When Nights Were Cold’ by Susanna Jones ever since it was on the Fiction Uncovered List 2012. I am a big fan of Fiction Uncovered, an initiative to give some books that might have gone under the radar in a particular year more attention, and it has lead me to some gems such as Ray Robinson’s ‘Forgetting Zoe’ and of course Catherine Hall’s ‘The Proof of Love’. I have most of the listed books in the TBR and seeing as ‘When Nights Were Cold’, one of 2012’s choices, was a Victorian tale (and you know how I love those) with an icy and Arctic twist the timing seemed perfect for it to be read.

*** Mantle Books, hardback, 2012, fiction, 341 pages, kindly sent by the publisher

Grace Farringdon seems a woman who is rather out of sync with her time, if only by half a decade or so, from a young age she has an obsession with the polar regions and follows the adventures of Ernest Shackleton and his expeditions into this unknown frontier. Being the late Victorian period, and though the suffragette movement is beginning, this is not seen as ‘the done thing’ for a young woman who should be only occupied by the idea of marrying well. Grace exasperates her father, and mother particularly, all the more when she applies, and secretly seeks funding from a distant aunt, to enrol in a woman’s college where she sets up the Antarctic Exploration Society with fellow students, and an unlikely set of friends, Leonora Locke (daughter of an infamous actress), Winifred Hooper (a meek woman set to become a doctor’s wife) and Cecily Parr (orphaned daughter of two mountaineers). These three women decide to defy conventions further by becoming mountaineers themselves, only what happens to them becomes more chilling than the Welsh and Alpine mountains they start to explore.

“I scratched a few unsatisfactory sentences on my sheet, tucked it into the envelope, placed it on my dressing table. The letters informed our families that we had died knowing all the risks we faced and that we loved them and were sorry for the pain we caused, but that we had done it for the greater good of womankind and it was better to have tried and failed than to have stayed home embroidering tablecloths. Locke addressed her letter to her parents and Geoffrey, and Parr’s was addressed to her aunt and uncle in Wales. She grumbled that this was unnecessary and would put a curse on the adventure. And it’s only the Breithorn, she said, but she wrote the letter nevertheless and placed it on her bedside table.”

There were lots of things that I enjoyed about ‘When Nights Were Cold’, the fact that the whole way through there was a hint of something awful having happened at some point and the mystery behind it, the strained relationships of Grace and her mother and father, the difficulty she had adjusting from being alone and independent to coming home, why her sister had disappeared for fifteen years, the sibling rivalry for a certain Mr Black (a very clever strand in the book that twisted and turned itself), the stories of Shackleton and Scott and their adventures we hear through Grace and, what seemed to me, the main heart of the novel which is the tale of four women who wanted to do something bold to break the mould which Victorian society had women bound in still.

There is though a ‘however’ coming along. As much as I loved all of these strands, and I really did, there was almost too much going on and this caused me issues for two reasons. The first was that the book worked its best when Grace was retelling the tales of the Antarctic explorers and indeed when she was out in the Welsh mountains training for the forthcoming Alps, and then the atmosphere and adventure (and it was gripping, scary and dramatic) when they were there. It was in these situations that Grace came alive and so the book did. When there was less going on, and in these testing times we get a real insight into Grace, when she is at home with all that going on, and the possible madness of her sister, Grace (who I occasionally wondered if had gone slightly insane) sort of retreats from the reader while the story takes hold. I only felt I got to know her a bit and that was when she was in the mountains.

That said that does link to the second slight issue I had. There is a mystery, in fact two actually, bubbling in the background of the book the whole way through. Interestingly you don’t see it until about a quarter of the way through the book and its one that really makes the final chapters of the book whizz by with you gripped. Again, like Grace’s character, this mystery seems to get swallowed up by the domestic side of the tale and a possible love story, which again could have been given more space to really grab the reader. I felt like I was being pulled along by lots of great factors and yet they were fighting for space with each other. What I really enjoyed about the book was also what was occasionally causing me to pause with the book.

What I am saying, probably rather badly and in much too lengthy a way, is that actually I think ‘When Nights Were Cold’ was a very good book, but had it been about 200 pages longer it could have been an absolutely amazing epic. Susanna Jones’ prose, characters and atmosphere of the sinister and dangerous Alps are all marvellous I just need it all to have longer to unfold especially with Grace and all her secrets. I think had Susanna Jones had longer to do all this, and more pages and time for the reader to be involved in everything that was going on, I could easily have loved this book as much as ‘Gillespie and I’ by Jane Harris. That said I enjoyed it a lot, I was just left wanting more – which is a good thing overall, I think.

Who else has read ‘When Nights Were Cold’ and what did you make of it, it is one of those books I wish I could discuss over coffee at a book group, especially with its ending. Have any of you read any of Susanna Jones other novels, for this is her fourth, and what did you make of them? Have you read any of the other 2012 Fiction Uncovered titles, or indeed the 2011?



Filed under Fiction Uncovered, Mantle Publishing, Review, Susanna Jones

12 responses to “When Nights Were Cold – Susanna Jones

  1. Holy cow. I have not even heard of most of these titles… Wow. That doesn’t happen very often. Any others you might mention that you have read?…

    • No only these ones so far I think. The lovely Dovegreyreader is one of the judges for Fiction Uncovered 2013 so am excited about this new list coming later this year too.

      I will be reading the Dan Rhodes soon because he’s one of my favourite authors. Not sure why I’ve not read it sooner actually.

  2. Well, at -40 here in Ottawa, Canada, the title is especially poignant right now 🙂 Wonderful review, thank you.

  3. Thanks for an amazing review

  4. David

    I think I might have dismissed this one when I saw it last year, Simon, but it looks rather intriguing. From your review I was assuming this was a debut novel as it sounds like she chucks rather too much into the mix, but I see it isn’t. Still, I like the idea of it being about a Victorian woman defying convention and the mountaineering/exploration appeals to me too. Look out for ‘Above All Things’ by Tanis Rideout (out in March I think) if you enjoyed that aspect – a novel about Mallory and Everest that manages to have you on the edge of your seat even though you already know the outcome.

    I’ve read two of the 2012 Fiction Uncovered list – ‘My Former Heart’ and ‘The Light of Amsterdam’ which are both very good indeed, especially the Connolly; and three from the 2011 list – ‘Disputed Land’ (not Tim Pears’ best but still okay – his first couple of novels are still my favourites of his), ‘Proof of Love’ (you love it I know, I was less impressed), and ‘The London Satyr’ (not Robert Edric’s best either, though a vast improvement on ‘Salvage’ which he published the year before. The problem with Edric is that all his books – or at least the six I’ve read – are very similar. And if you read him and find the narrator irritating, don’t bother with any of his others – they’re all like that!).

    • There is a lot going for this book and intriguing it definitely is. Interesting that you mention the debut novel feeling about it as I had that debut feeling whilst reading it – something I will be talking about over the weekend – and then discovered that it was her fourth. This for me is one of those books which just needs to go BIGGER, it has so much it wants to say and had I been working on this book with Jones I would have made her make it longer because its so full of facinating parts yet as they arent fully, fully fleshed out it sort of suffers because of its own brilliance.

      I have both My Former Heart and The Light of Amsterdam on the TBR, I might give the former a whirl. I also really want to read This is Life by Dan Rhodes but I am a big, big fan of his anyway.

  5. I’ve been wanting to read this, actually. I love Victorian and I love cold weather (in books, not in real life, though I’m stuck in it for the next several months) so it looks perfect to me. I’ll second David’s recommendation for Above All Things by Tanis Rideout, which I thought was fantastic.

  6. Pingback: Tom-All-Alone’s – Lynn Shepherd | Savidge Reads

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s